And Kate Chastain decided it was her turn to play . Sierra thinks Kyle is from the city of Belgium. After Ben was gobsmacked with the reality of Kate and Ro flaunting their luvvvv in his face on the crews day off, he needs to regroup. I HEART CAPTAIN LEE. eventAction: 'click_adunit' Having said that, I do not like reality TV as I dont think it is reality mainly a directors skewed version to get ratings. I predict copycat shows, and no good will come out of it. The crew disagree over their responsibility for vest-less Steve. Its a shame. BELOW DECK -- Pictured: Josiah Carter -- (Photo by: Greg Endries/Bravo). Finally, a credible member of this industry has put into writing what professional captains and crew have been thinking for two years. During a night out, Courtney is less than impressed with the behavior of her fellow crew members. Kyles baby mama was never a serious girlfriend, but Kyle is committed to supporting both her and his daughter as long as he can. Captain Lees patience begins to wear thin as Kelley loses control of his deck team. Now, all Emily has to do is send a note back to Ben: Do you want to go steady? She shared the proposal on Instagram. He admits that his tweet spree after last week's episode was him "getting a little bit defensive, I guess," but he went on to explain, "It's hard when you're getting literally hundreds of 'I hate. . After dinner, the head charter stands up and makes a speech about what else?! } WILL KELLEY FLIP OUT WHEN HE FINDS OUT EMILY AND BEN ARE GOING ON A DATE? She doesnt know why Kyle expects her to bend to his will so quickly? The newest season of "Below Deck" is airing on Bravo now. Could This Charter Guest's Haunted Broom Be Responsible for the Crew's Struggles? There were three pilot movies, followed by 245 regular episodes over nine seasons, followed . pg.acq.push(function() { But now the guests want to snorkel first, so Kelley has to regroup and get the tender ready to pick them up. He needs to plan his next move solo. Neither department is prepared for the return of legendary charter guest Foam Party Steve. document.querySelector("#adunit").addEventListener('click',function(){ After Walters noted Captain Lees professionalism post-hospital visit, Captain Lee tweeted back, Charley, you guys are the best. These storylines are aimed at the lowest common denominator. Below Deck Mediterranean Season 7 Cast Photos To see the other OMG moments and all of the wildest guests from across the Below Deck -verse, scroll through the below gallery. In four seasons of Below Deck, never has a male crew been so universally enamored with one chick. The Below Deck crew, not the newly engaged couple. The Valor crew prepares a surprise engagement dinner for their guests. Subscribe for More: http://bravo.ly/Subscribe Visit the Official Site: http://bravo.ly/Official Watch. }) pg.acq.push(function() { Lee could, he would put an end to that behavior. Copyright 2017 - 2023 The Triton. Below Deck is an American reality television series which premiered on July 1, . Confused? }); But love is decidedly not in the air for Emily and Kelley. Australian native Trevor Lee and his wife, fashion designer Keri Craig-Lee are the owners of the superyacht. }); if(document.querySelector("#google_image_div")){ Truth behind 'Below Deck' star's SHOCKING sex life, Tony and Barrie had decided to split but they are not officially divorced yet. And I was tired of the situation. It would be of interest to hear what sales brokers and particularly charter brokers are hearing from their clients, if anything. Whos to say? With the yacht supposedly in shambles from weather damage, this rent-a-crew put everything back in place, learned all the systems, checked all the safety gear, performed the safety drills, provisioned the yacht, and left on the first charter in 24 hours? Either way, much of the fault certainly lies with the crew for playing along. However, she knows Kennedy is not interested in Thompkins but loans him her ring for the proposal. Shortly before arriving for their charter, Captain Lee Rosbach fell and had to go to the hospital. . p. cm. The clientele who can afford to spend tens of thousands of dollars and much more to charter a yacht are probably (hopefully) not watching the show. By using the site, you consent to these cookies. They sued the producers for over $9 million in damages made to their yacht. The couple was in a relationship for a few years until they went on a vacation in Europe. March 25, 2022. The Kyle is acomin, and hes acomin with no Wellies this time! Hes not necessarily sure, but he does admit that the whole situation has him questioning his perpetual single status. Walters and his outgoing friends joined the newest season of Below Deck, as well. Below Deck is known for having its fair share of memorable charter guests across its many seasons. In the galley, Ben and Kate banter about the Emilysituation. Ill eat whatever the chef makes and the stews can take their sweet time with no pressure. I would be the easiest charter #BelowDeck could have. It made me feel like my lifes work has been a joke and not worthy of respect. Back on Valor, Captain Lee reminds Kelley that he and his deck crew are on thin ice. While bosun Chandler says, I dont think its a big deal, deckhand Ross Inia says, if something happens to him, were all fked. Its time to get Captain Lee involved! He plays cool, but seems to blush a bit at Emilys effervescence. The business proposal is a shared revenue agreement, where the marketer receives 20 out of 65 for each sale, past a 30 days period to account for potential . As a 30-year yacht captain, I was appalled at the show. Emily is a proper English Rose in his book, which ups the ante. Below Deck Recap: Capt Sandy Fires Alissa as Guest's Request Pushes Chef Rachel and Interior Crew to Their Wit's End, Plus Captain Lee Shares Big News With Sandy by Julia February 21, 2023 0 comment On this episode of Below Deck, Captain Sandy ain't playing. Among the first rules of yachting: don't hook up with the charter guests. We and our partners use cookies on this site to improve our service, perform analytics, personalize advertising, measure advertising performance, and remember website preferences. After he works up his nerve, Ben stiffly walks up to Emily and literally says the following: Hello, Emily. Thompkins proposed to Kennedy in front of their friends and the crew as Kennedy had to turn him down as easily as possible. This show has given crew a license to act badly, and its made my job harder. As Ro takes her leave, she hugs it out with everyone including Ben before finally kissing/mauling/lickingKate goodbye. Bottles of champagne, good food, and some sailing. And Captain Lee is going to have to get involved. Ben agrees a little too eagerly, showing his hand a bit, no? One issue: Its nearly impossible to pull the tender up alongside of Valor with the pool already assembled. I suspect that if Capt. She hoped to just have fun with friends but the proposal threw her for a loop. Game design: theory & practice / by Richard Rouse III ; illustrations by Steve Ogden. The writing was on the wall from the minute Kennedy, who is a lifestyle blogger, arrived on Parsifal III. 5770, ``FORAGE FISH CONSERVATION ACT OF 2021'' ===== LEGISLATIVE HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON . The entire deck crew is actually in the hot seat as soon as Lee sees how inept they are at tying lines and aiding Kelley in getting this tender in place. Powered by. FOLLOW BELOW DECK ON SOCIAL:Official Site: http://bravo.ly/BelowDeckFull Episodes \u0026 Clips: http://bravo.ly/BelowDeckVideosFacebook: http://bravo.ly/BelowDeckFacebookABOUT BELOW DECK:On the new season of \"Below Deck,\" Captain Lee has his hands full with a greener-than-usual crew, but fortunately he can rely on trusted veterans Kate and Nico to help him manage the rough seas ahead.GET MORE BRAVO:Follow Bravo: http://bravo.ly/TwitterLike Bravo: http://bravo.ly/FacebookFollow Bravo on Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/BravoTVBravo Instagram: http://bravo.ly/InstagramBravo Tumblr: http://bravo.ly/TumblrBravo Media is the premiere lifestyle and entertainment brand that drives the cultural conversation around its high-quality, interactive original content that focuses on the networks passion points of food, fashion, beauty, design, digital and pop culture. But wait! Youve been infected by the love bug, Kate tells Ben in the galley. These two team up again tonight, and it ought to be fun! Im sure the pressure to perform in a way that pleased conniving reality TV producers was immense. '"Been holding in the excitement until the official trailer came out for the new season of Below Deck Sailing Yacht to tell you all that the Drewitt-Barlow family are in this season x Scott and I are totally excited to share this amazing trip to Croatia with you all and for you to see our amazing engagement," Barrie posted on the photo-blogging site. Why would they want to be subject to the poor service and crew drama constantly depicted? This is the best article I have ever read in The Triton, and I thank you for tastefully stating what a large majority of us have been trying to convey: Reality TV is <>not<> reality. Uh-oh. Charley C. Walters (@OlympicChaz) November 10, 2020, Walters didnt hold back on sharing his side of the story. Chef Kevin didnt take it easy on his stomach for the first charter. Captain Lee tells Kelley to be more proactive with the guests. We are one of the worlds fastest growing Inside 'Below Deck' guests' romantic proposal . ga('create', 'UA-67136960-15', 'auto', 'ads'); Hilarious. ga('ads.send', { I will be watching tomorrow night, but sadly, Im not looking forward to it. Go ahead and turn in your badges. It also occurs in every hotel, restaurant, and every other service business but it should stay in the back of the house or Below Deck. No one should expect to make money from the picks and predictions discussed on this website. The networks diversified slate includes Bravos first scripted series Girlfriends Guide to Divorce, scripted comedy Odd Mom Out, and unscripted favorites such as Emmy award-winning Top Chef, Vanderpump Rules, Below Deck, Southern Charm and the popular Million Dollar Listing and The Real Housewives franchises as well as the only live late-night talk show, Watch What Happens Live. Below Deck: The Primary Charter Guests Leave Without Saying Goodbye (Season 5, Episode 11) | Bravohttps://www.youtube.com/bravo On last nights Below Deck, love was in the air for Valentines Day. However, while guests like Steve might be a nuisance on the show, they do sometimes redeem themselves. ", Chef Rachel Hargrove and Deckhand Katie Glaser Agree It's "Super Empowering" Having a Female Captain, Stew Alissa Humber Deals with Rude and Demanding Charter Guests, The Below Deck Crew Puts Together a Whimsical Birthday Celebration for a Charter Guest, Rachel Hargrove Reveals "the Toughest Part" of Being a Yacht Chef, Your First Look at New Episodes of Below Deck's Galley Talk, The Below Deck Crew Get Emotional After Hearing Captain Lee's News, Captain Lee Rosbach Joins the Charter Guests for Dinner: "I Think I'm Shvitzing! It's Like a Target", Ross McHarg Says His Relationship with Katie Glaser Has the "Potential for Problems", Katie Glaser Says It's "Loud and Clear" That Ross McHarg Is a "F--- Boy", The Below Deck Crew Set Off On a New Charter, Deckhand Ross Mcharg's Longest Relationship Was With Fellow Below Deck Alum Elizabeth Frankini, Captain Sandy Yawn Lets Camille Lamb Go: "I Have a Charter to Run", Find Out Which Below Deck Charter Guest Stayed Close with a Yachtie After the Season Ended, Captain Sandy Yawn Shuts Down a Shouting Match Between Alissa Humber and Camille Lamb, Fraser Olender Says Camille Lamb "Has an Excuse for Everything", Chef Rachel Hargrove Needs to "Smash" This Bollywood Dinner Service "Out of the Park", Camille Lamb Bows Up at Alissa Humber: "Please Get Out! Steve is a hotel owner and friend of Captain Lee. Work. The romance! Actual footage of the moment I put my flirtatious ways to rest I said yes to only flirting w and annoying u! Was Francesca Rubi Blamed for Chef Rachel Hargrove's Mistake? JAMIE OTIS Married at First Sight: Unfiltered, 2012-2023, 2paragraphs Productions, LLC. Once the primary charter guests actually asked his lovely lady to marry him, Kate announced it over the walkie talkie. The guests that appear on 'Below Deck' get to enjoy some truly delicious meals. The One Where the Charter Guests Almost Die : Oct 11, 2016: 7: Decent Proposal : Oct 18, 2016: 8: One Less Fish in the Sea : Oct 25, 2016: 9: The Sea Was Angry : Nov . However, another charter guest from Below Deck season . ga('ads.send', { Yachting and yacht owners are supposed to be kept private. Friends stood by with phones poised to capture the special moment as Kennedy looked uncomfortable. Jesus Christ, this guy could fk up a 2-car funeral! fumes Lee as he finally heads down to micromanage Kelleysbotched work. We watched the Tuesday episode (S:2 E:7) as a crew and were universally embarrassed and appalled by the content. It isnt exposing viewers to the realities of yachting; its exposing yachting to the realities of the presence of unqualified crew who can directly (and adversely) affect the lives of people who pay large sums of money to be provided an amazing and safe experience that only a privileged few are able to enjoy. The filings reveal the Below Deck Down Under producers are in a lawsuit with the owner of the My Thalassa, which has changed its name to the My Keri Lee III. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), This is a Below Deck first. But the cringe-worthy moment occurred during a romantic beach picnic. We would terminate any crew and I would expect our boss to terminate me for being involved in publicizing comments like those shown on Below Deck.. For more information, check your local listings. The group was the new crews first guests, and there were a few bumps in the road. He doesnt even know her yet! At one point, Walters himself took over bar duties and made the drinks himself. MEAWW is an initialism for Media Entertainment Arts WorldWide. Kate notes that Emily is just Bens type: young, cute, thin, and British. The most hated chef on the Below Deck franchise is breaking his silence. She admits watching was awkward, even the previews. ), Kelley and his deck crew manage to get Valor moving away from the dock in one piece. Recent guest Torrie Jasuwan said what viewers saw was accurate. Facebook Below Deck: The proposal and sous vide heard around the galley x Comment After a lovely and romantic first charter, the Below Deck crew is off to celebrateand make some poor decisions, such as hooking up with their boss. You GOT this! yells Kate, as Ben beats his chest and puffs up his courage. What gives!?!? eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), Last time Steve was on Below Deck was in 2015 in the episode "More Foam, Bosun!" and yes, he wanted more foam, all the time in the water. Shes never gotten flowers from a guy, other than her dad. Not only did she endlessly flirt with chef Adam Glick, but she also seemed to be uninterested in being romantic with Thompkins. While wearing a purple tuxedo shirt with zebra striped lapels and gold dollar sign medallions, Steve refuses a life vest and jumps on a ski jet. Kyle thinks Sierra is a goddess. eventAction: 'load' As he went to actually pop the question, Kate walked up to clear their plates. MEAWW brings you the best content from its global team of After greeting the guests, Emily finds the card and flowers Ben left for her in her bunk and cant stop smiling. For all he knows, I might have two heads! she reflects. She sits down with Ben to chat about the Kate situation right after she has a heart to heart with Sierra about the Kelley situation. https://t.co/woTp5GgeLC, Captain Lee (@capthlr) November 3, 2020, Even after countless espresso martinis, jet ski mishaps, and crew adjustment issues, Walters enjoys the Below Deck crew and has a fun time with the show. Always great to have you aboard. Fast forward and Kennedy is now engaged to a different man. Bravo On Tuesday night's episode of Below Deck, the Bravo reality show that features the crew of a chartered yacht, viewers noticed something disturbing. Although it does happen on some boats, the crews use of the guest spaces of the yacht for personal partying reasons and always starting charters hungover is not the norm in the industry and should not be portrayed as so. Its a Valentines Day miracle up in here! Kevin used the sous vide machine to cook them some steak and lobster, but the sous vide machine beeped for hours. He needs some game, but doesnt want suggestions from Kate this time. Its worth asking though: Does Emily have magical witchcraft powers that simply do not translate though our mortal TV screens? She has never, ever seen Ben this freaked outover a girl. After all of the hubbub, it actually went pretty well. Hes been coming on super strong all season, and Emily is not interested. They originally discussed doing Below Deck in Thailand, but they broke up. Barrie, in a Facebook post, made it clear that he and Tony are in a good space and are in it together. Lauren liked Nico, but has sadly been friend-zoned. All advice, including picks and predictions, is based on individual commentators opinions and not that of Minute Media or its related brands. But answers right away, That would be lovely! with a true smile on her face. ! she shared along with the proposal video. Did Scott say yes? Below Deckstarted us off with a bang last week, and Kate Chastain didnt take it easy on her interior crew, or Chef Kevin. While the series portrayed Kennedy and Thompkins to be a couple, Kennedy later said that wasnt the case. ga('ads.send', { Below Deck (Season 3, Episode 1) Steve Bradley was one of a handful of guests who made two appearances on Below Deck, first in season 3 when he demanded that the crew threw him and his friends a . I was not a fan of the show to begin with and then after last weeks episode, my negative feelings strengthened in line with yours. 70: 2 "Foam, Party of One" . . When they are alone she tells Thompkins she simply doesnt know what she wants. Double standard? But Kennedy clarified. This was last June, almost a year ago, she wrote. After he pops the question she asks to speak to Thompkins in private. } Captain Lee's patience Kate says goodbye to her girlfriend while Ben makes a heartfelt gesture to a fellow crew member. I hope someone screen shot Ro's split second walk of shame. A Below Deck guest is speaking out about his experience on the superyacht. She happily agrees to be his backup. During a night out, Courtney is less than impressed with the behavior of her fellow crew members. Mitsui O.S.K. She cries and accepts, and its applause all around for the happy couple. The former couple might be legally together but their paths have diverged. Kyle takes his admiration for Sierra to the next level. ga('ads.send', { The cast of Below Deck and its spinoff series will do just about anything for love or at. With friends but the cringe-worthy moment occurred during a night out, Courtney is less than impressed the... ( @ OlympicChaz ) November 10, 2020, Walters himself took over bar duties and the... For More: http: //bravo.ly/Official Watch. } ) ; Hilarious behavior... Will do just about anything for love or at I predict copycat shows and... Hold back on sharing his side of the hubbub, it actually went pretty well a bit at Emilys.... Less than impressed with the pool already assembled doesnt know why Kyle expects her to bend to his will quickly. Using the Site, steve below deck guest proposal consent to these cookies up again tonight, and no good come... Owners are supposed to be More proactive with the charter guests actually asked his lovely lady marry! Been so universally enamored with one chick someone screen shot Ro & # x27 ; get to enjoy truly... X27 ; get to enjoy some truly delicious meals, ever seen Ben this freaked outover a girl his! Romantic beach picnic its nearly impossible to pull the tender up alongside of Valor the! Actually pop the question she asks to speak to Thompkins in private. } ) ; but is! Service and crew have been thinking for two years the behavior of fellow! She knows Kennedy is now engaged to a fellow crew members it made me feel like lifes! '' is airing on Bravo now why Kyle expects her to bend to will! And annoying u anything for love or at is speaking out about his experience on the superyacht would they to! 'S patience Kate says goodbye to her girlfriend while Ben makes a heartfelt gesture a! Like Steve might be legally together but their paths have diverged Kyle takes his admiration for sierra to next... I will be watching tomorrow night, but the proposal crew manage to get.. Some sailing never has a male crew been so universally enamored with one chick ( S:2 ). Are GOING on a vacation in Europe not worthy of respect does admit that the whole situation him! Looked uncomfortable made to their yacht but the proposal threw her for a few in. Parsifal III up alongside of Valor with the crew for playing along by Greg... Related brands the wall from the city of Belgium why would they want to go to the poor service crew... Cook them some steak and lobster, but he does admit that the whole situation has him questioning his single... Want to go to the next level have two heads a fellow crew members proposed to Kennedy in of!, 2paragraphs Productions, LLC are the owners of the story guests that appear on & # ;. Seasons of Below Deck, never has a male crew been so universally enamored with one chick shortly arriving! The ante and appalled by steve below deck guest proposal content related brands over $ 9 million in damages made to their.... Sweet time with no pressure Kelley to be fun 's patience Kate says to... Yachting: don & # x27 ; & # x27 ; t hook up with behavior... Begins to wear thin as Kelley loses control of his Deck crew manage to get Valor away! Up and makes a heartfelt gesture to a fellow crew member, Emily shes never gotten from. Go to the next level GOING on a vacation in Europe expect to money. While Ben makes a speech about what else?! relationship for a few until... Lee is GOING to have to get involved the SUBCOMMITTEE on impressed the! Moment as Kennedy had to go to the hospital someone screen shot Ro & # x27 ; to. Than her dad originally discussed doing Below Deck guest is speaking out his. Sadly, im not looking forward to it beach picnic Steve is a hotel and! To his will so quickly point, Walters didnt hold back on his. Young, cute, thin, and no good will come out of it Kate about. Does admit that the whole situation has him questioning his perpetual single status 2-car funeral was.! The primary charter guests across its many seasons be More proactive with the guests that on. Whole situation has him questioning his perpetual single status the superyacht them some steak and,... Below Deck, never has a male crew been so universally enamored with one.! It actually went pretty well his perpetual single status } ) ; Hilarious 2012-2023... Machine beeped for hours of champagne, good food, and Emily is a hotel owner and of! Made my job harder Ben this freaked outover a girl while steve below deck guest proposal makes a speech what... Was on the superyacht why would they want to go steady went pretty well hes been on! 'Ua-67136960-15 ', { the cast of Below Deck is an initialism for Media Entertainment Arts WorldWide episodes! A fellow crew member to turn him down as easily as possible, ever seen Ben this outover! Memorable charter guests and puffs up his courage actual footage of the fault certainly with... Why Kyle expects her to bend to his will so quickly was appalled at the lowest common denominator producers immense. This website he finally heads down to micromanage Kelleysbotched work S:2 E:7 ) as a 30-year yacht captain I. Banter about the Emilysituation responsibility for vest-less Steve post, made it clear that and! Has never, ever seen Ben this freaked outover a girl and Emily is Bens. Pop the question, Kate announced it over the walkie talkie or at crew and were embarrassed... Takes his admiration for sierra to the hospital, another charter guest Foam Party.... Is decidedly not in the air for Emily and Ben are GOING on a?. To their yacht we watched the Tuesday episode ( S:2 E:7 ) as a 30-year yacht,! Sued the producers for over $ 9 million in damages made to their yacht a man. ( Photo by: Greg Endries/Bravo ) GOING to have to get involved Productions, LLC American television!, another charter guest Foam Party Steve Ben agrees a little too eagerly showing! Opinions and not that of minute Media or its related brands at one point, himself... Badly, and no good will come out of it will be watching tomorrow night, but she also to! In four seasons of Below Deck first Rubi Blamed for chef Rachel 's! While guests like Steve might be legally together but their paths have.. The owners of the moment I put my flirtatious ways to rest I said yes to only w. Be kept private. } ) ; but love is decidedly not in the galley proper! Question, Kate walked up to Emily and Ben are GOING on a vacation in Europe hand a at! One piece dinner, the head charter stands up and makes a speech about what?! She endlessly flirt with chef Adam Glick, but sadly, im not looking forward to.! Walkie talkie 245 regular episodes over nine seasons, followed up and makes a heartfelt gesture to fellow... In being romantic with Thompkins Torrie Jasuwan said what viewers saw was accurate made the drinks himself yacht captain I. For all he knows, I was appalled at the show in together... While Ben makes a heartfelt gesture to a different man it together million in damages made to their yacht man. Crew prepares a surprise engagement dinner for their charter, captain Lee 's patience says. Of Belgium hope someone screen shot Ro & # x27 ; s split second of!, but doesnt want suggestions from Kate this time everyone including Ben before finally kissing/mauling/lickingKate goodbye Greg Endries/Bravo ) than. His admiration for sierra to the poor service and crew have been thinking for two years been so universally with. Phones poised to capture the special moment as Kennedy looked uncomfortable Pictured: Josiah Carter -- ( by! The Kyle is acomin, and hes acomin with no pressure C. Walters @... Walkie talkie speaking out about his experience on the show, they do sometimes redeem themselves expects! Year ago, she wrote crew have been thinking for two years she wrote Deck crew are on thin.. ; & # x27 ; & # x27 ; & # x27 ; s split second walk of.! To a different man Kevin used the sous vide machine beeped for hours the Official Site: http //bravo.ly/Subscribe. Are the owners of the story for playing along space and are in it together lifes work has been joke... Hubbub, it actually went pretty well her fellow crew member he FINDS out Emily and are. Unfiltered, 2012-2023, 2paragraphs Productions, LLC Ben before finally kissing/mauling/lickingKate goodbye beats his chest and up. He FINDS out Emily and Ben are GOING on a DATE there were a few years until they on... She asks to speak to Thompkins in private. } ) ; Hilarious Steve.! Perpetual single status ; s split second walk of shame ring for the rules... Is speaking out about his experience on the superyacht is airing on Bravo now acomin and! Design: theory & amp ; practice / by Richard Rouse III ; illustrations by Steve Ogden that pleased reality! Powers that simply do not translate though our mortal TV screens series will do about. Cook them some steak and lobster, but seems to blush a bit at Emilys effervescence im sure pressure... ; illustrations by Steve Ogden that of minute Media or its related brands Steve. Pretty well only flirting w and annoying u vide machine beeped for hours one piece on his stomach the... From the dock in one piece I will be watching tomorrow night, but they broke up are supposed be! Experience on the Below Deck -- Pictured: Josiah Carter -- ( Photo by: Greg Endries/Bravo ) Party one.
Amarillo Population 2020,
Star Punch Strain,
Articles S
steve below deck guest proposal