Zoom is a mobile application that saw the light of day in 2011. A lack of comparable substitute alternatives makes an industry less competitive and increases profit potential for the firms in the industry but potentially could find it hard to change direction or innovate. This is a positive and needed development since, coupled with bargaining power of buyers, it can help to keep new models honest in terms of how they operate. Threat of new entrants Threat of substitutes Bargaining power of Are there one or more substitutes available in the market. Are there any limitations to its use? Watch them until they make this move or that move. High). This group may collectively have an unmet need or a weak spot. It explains the substitute threat, and how to detect and analyse it within your industry. In addition, the long-term revenue stream from the digital services may be worth far more than the one time sale of the physical product. A specific example would be a consumer buying fish because they are cheaper than meat from pork or cattle. These include personal computers, tablet devices, and smartphones, among others. For more information, see our Privacy Policy. Youve probably already heard of group chat appHouseparty, which hit the headlines during the coronavirus lockdown after rumours started circulating of a hack. There is also the trend to move from government owned carriers to more privately owned enterprises. Say youre a manufacturer of steel car bodies. Based on the external factors enumerated in this Porters Five Forces analysis, Walmart experiences the following intensities of the five forces in the retail industry environment: Competitive rivalry or competition Strong. %PDF-1.5 Digital business changes the rules by lowering the traditional barriers to entry. Food & We offer a free no-obligation consultation. In order to solidify the new relationship, consumers may need to be reassured that their needs are met and possibly in better ways than before. WebThree of Michael Porter's Five Forces deal with competition: 1) industry rivalry, 2) threat of new entrants, and 3) threat of substitutes. Sign in to Zoom Events. As previously mentioned, the COVID-19 pandemic played a significant role in Zooms sudden rise to success. Lets look at each of these five forces and examine the role and impact of digital business: Theres no doubt that digital business is changing the nature of competition. A segment of buyers may hire human accountants to outsource complexity and time in preparing their own tax returns. Here's what you'll find in our full Understanding Michael Porter summary : Carrie has been reading and writing for as long as she can remember, and has always been open to reading anything put in front of her. The threat of substitutes is one of Porters five forces that explains how other products might threaten your product. If an airline operates on that route, it must compete with all other airlines on that route as well as any possible ground routes such as car rentals, buses and trains. Porters Five Forces Analysis of Apple covers the companys competitive landscape as well as the factors affecting its sector. 2021 All Rights Reserved, Threat of Substitutes: Impacts, Factors, and Examples, Summary: Timeline of the Fall of Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos, Promotion Strategy of Apple: Key Promotional Activities, Distribution Strategy of Apple: Channels and Components, Apple HomePod (2nd Gen) Quick Review: Pros and Cons, Apple HomePod Mini Quick Review: Pros and Cons, The Major Subfields of Artificial Intelligence, Importance of Natural Language Processing in AI, YouTube Music Quick Review: Pros and Cons, A Quick Guide to the Common Causes of Hair Loss, Link Between Lucid Dreaming and Metacognition, Study: How Alcohol Impairs Sleep and Daytime Function. It's possible to encounteran issue whereZoom removesall alternative hosts when ameeting is edited. Global recessions have also meant cost cutting exercises for most airlines in the industry and often less travel in the part of consumers. Like this article? Coke and Pepsi are not substitutes because they are the same cola-based carbonated beverage. Substitutes have the potential to reduce demand and prices for traditional law firm services. Password reset instructions will be sent to your E-mail. The Cisco WebEx scam reads: Alert!" This profit potential is of course the same for your Direct and Indirect competitors too. Is it as good or better than what you can offer? <> This component of Porters Five Forces framework determines the strength of substitute products in attracting customers. Why are some industries consistently more profitable than others? endobj A key part of Porters five forces is what is he calls the threat of substitutes. The issue occurs only for recurring meetings. a fragmented supplier group is bad for suppliers but good for you). Get on promotion fasstrack and increase tour lifetime salary. Take note that the other four are the bargaining powers of suppliers, threat of new entrants, the bargaining power of buyers, and the intensity of competitive rivalry. Can't find what you are looking for? Its led to a massive surge in users, but the work from home ethos during the current COVID-19 crisis has resulted in a bad couple of weeks for popular video conferencing app Zoom. 3 0 obj For more generic, undifferentiated products the threat is always higher that from more unique products. Zooms also suffered from vulnerabilities affecting users of operating systems including Windows and Mac OSwhich have since been fixed. At this point, try to understand why an alternate solution may be appealing to a consumer. The analysis focuses on measuring the companys position based on forces like threat of new entrants, threat of substitutes, bargaining power of buyers, bargaining power of suppliers and competitive rivalry. Dont click on links in emails without checking where they come from first. Landlines and Mobile Phones: These two are also within the same telecommunication industry. So Porters threat of substitutes shows us that a low threat of substitute products makes your industry more attractive. WebThreat of substitutes (from Porters five forces analysis) occurs when companies within one industry are forced to compete with industries producing substitute products or services. If so, the threat of substitutes is high. In more generic products, there are often more than one ways to address a particular need. ApplesFaceTimeis a perfect alternative to Zoom, as long as everyone whos part of the meeting or chat has access to an Apple device. We aim to empower our readership by delivering concise informative content. Suppliers can accelerate or slow down the adoption of a digitally based business model based upon how it impacts their own situation. But landlines are wired mediums of voice communication while mobile phones are wireless communication devices that provide voice, text messaging, access to the internet, and other functionalities. Troubleshooting: Zoom Desktop Client for Linux to Require Key Pair Update by November 2, 2022, Web/Video Conference Problem: Audio Echoes, Zoom Alternative Host Removed when Editing a Meeting, Zoom Issue: Registration Data or Reports Lost Following Changes to Registration Settings, Zoom Issue: Restore Zoom Integration with Office 365 Calendar, Zoom Problem: "You cannot log into your Zoom account using this method", Zoom Problem: Can't Sign In to cornell.zoom.us, Zoom Problem: Not Meeting Host Error Message, Zoom Problem: Users Cannot Cut and Paste Email Addresses into Alternative Hosts Field When Scheduling Meetings, Zoom Problem: You See Random Characters Instead of Your Name, Yammer Cleanup and Maintenance Spring 2023, PMI Ithaca Branch Hybrid Event March 15, 2023, Higher Ed DevOps Virtual Meetup March 2, 2023. No one of these video chat apps is perfect, but they can each be used for different purposes. For food delivery, substitutes are eating in restaurants, microwaved food, and groceries. Number of Substitutes: There are several substitute products in the consumer electronics industry that provide almost the same functionalities. Entrepreneurial Insights based on the concept of Porters 5 Forces. The threat is low if there is strong brand loyalty. In addition, chain stores such as Starbucks now offer a large variety of products that cater to different tastes. Its a higher value for the same price, or same value for lower price, or variations thereof. The bargaining power of suppliers and customers makes it possible to realize the decision-making power of so-called external actors, whether they are partners or customers, who are, of course, essential for the proper functioning of the application. When it was invented in the 19th century, the product was intended to be used as a medicine. Once the target audience has been identified, a company may want to find ways to interact with these people and create a relationship with them. Rivals arent just competing with each other. The five forces are the: It is important that you are strategically positioned within your industry to defend yourself from these forces and then go on the attack by manipulating them to your advantage. High). Good examples are the legal and business issues surfacing around the digital-sharing economy (i.e. Theyre also engaged in a struggle for profits with all the other players in the ecosystem like customers, who would always like to pay less and get more, and are eager to substitute a product for a better alternative. The competitive threat of substitution is weak in affecting Apple Inc.s computing technology, consumer electronics, and online services business. Instead log into the app directly, and see if any action needs to be taken. Customers and consumers have amassed far more bargaining power today due to instant access to information, insights from social media including access to reviews and feedback, low switching costs via digital channels, price sensitivity, access to substitute products and services with greater ease of use and convenience, as well as increased industry competitiveness as a result of the other forces. Analyse the danger and give each business a threat rating and plan to counter the risk. This can even happen at an industry scale, where in the effort to compete with companies within the industry can overshadow threats from the outside. Webyour Zoom sessions, reduce the chances of unwanted attendees, and equip you to quickly deal with the rascals. The FBI Says Its Leaders Pocketed $4 Million And Left Members With Thousands In Unpaid Medical Bills, privacy policy detailing intrusive data collection practices, Zoom video recordings exposed in an unsecured cloud database online, extraordinary growth of 10 million to 200 million daily users, announced a number of new security measures, thinks its a smear campaign and has offered $1 million to anyone who can prove this to be true. Need assistance with an IT@Cornell service. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. However, the privacy policy does outline some intrusive data collection practices, so you need to head to your settings, use private mode, and turn off location tracking. A low threat of substitute increases your potential profit capability. Taking these situations into account, Ivewritten a guideon how to use Zoom securely as possible. When scheduling meetings, users cannot copy and paste a list of alternative hosts into the Alternative Hosts field. There are three things to know about how a rascal can disrupt your If you loose network Overview We reviewed their content and use your feedback to keep the quality high. Sometimes, your workplace insists on using Zoom, or in my caseonline exercise classes utilize the app. The threat is high if consumers can readily purchase substitute products either because they are cheaper, have better product selling points, and are geographically accessible. Sign up for a free trial here . Experts are tested by Chegg as specialists in their subject area. In effect, tomorrows leader may not be someone you know. If it is high, the threat of substitution is low. Furthermore, it is also low of consumers have more penchant toward a particular product. <>/ExtGState<>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/Annots[ 25 0 R 26 0 R] /MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> <>>> Your email address will not be published. The threat of substitutes is the availability of other products that a customer could purchase from outside an industry. Are there any barriers that may stop a customer from switching? Meta Says It Now Looks Like Basic Spam. The availability of close substitute products will make your industry more competitive. The analysis focuses on measuring the companys position based on forces like threat of new entrants, threat of substitutes, bargaining power of buyers, bargaining power of suppliers and competitive rivalry. Forbesspoke to ESET security researcher Lukas Stefanko to see if there were any major cybersecurity concerns and he said there was nothing to be worried about. The FBI Says Its Leaders Pocketed $4 Million And Left Members With Thousands In Unpaid Medical Bills, misleading claims about the platform being end to end encrypted, implementing measures to try and be better. How innovation, efficiency and intelligence across the infrastructure ecosystem is finding a kindred spirit in digital twins. User Experience A Christian Ministry Promised An Obamacare Alternative. <> Copyright 2023 IDG Communications, Inc. A company can keep a check on possible substitutes by doing the following: Identify the problems that can be solved by your product or service? Lenovo Late Night I.T. It's possible to encounteran issue whereZoom removesall alternative hosts when ameeting is edited. The above discussion on SWOT analysis Zoom helped us understand the company's strategic position. Rivalry among competitors. Some users have indeed found their contact details on other sites, which is, of course, not acceptable. Then, the apps users started to report an increase in so-called Zoom bombing, seeing uninvited guests crashing meetings and chats. Use SPIN Strategy, How Corporate Exploitation & Abuse Causes Suffering. Examples of substitutes are meat, poultry, and fish; landlines and cellular telephones; airlines, automobiles, trains, and ships; beer and wine; and so on. Some of these conditions are: As mentioned previously, substitutes are not immediately recognizable since they are often from outside the industry a company operates within. Michael Porter argues that five forces influence competition and long-term investments. The more there are, the greater the threat, much like the competition. Solving a segments problems better than alternatives. In the case of an application like Zoom, who are the main suppliers? endobj Threat here is from competitors who may offer better rewards, better prices or a better flying experience. For those looking for a caffeinated drink, there is always coffee and tea, both of which are now available in a myriad of flavors and tastes. Whether because you're getting Zoom's "Your connection is unstable" warning or because you need to reduce your network usage to stay under a data cap, there are several strategies you can try to reduce your bandwidth and data usage during Zoom meetings. Smartphones are substitutes because they also provide the same functionalities but they are based on different technologies. The third scam discovered by Proofpoint is aimed at U.S. based users working in industries such as technology, accounting, aerospace, energy, healthcare, telecommunications, transportation, government, and manufacturing companies. Choose cover letter template and write your cover letter. Carrie worked in book publishing for several years before getting an MFA in Creative Writing. Zoomwhich has seen anextraordinary growth of 10 million to 200 million daily usersin a matter of months as COVID-19 took holdis quickly trying to make its service more secure and private. It has to be Houseparty. We're all about your competitive advantage. If these collected miles are divided over multiple airlines, benefits are also divided and slow to accumulate. To understand better substitutes and their impact, the following are specific examples of businesses and industries threatened by them: Luxury Fashion Brands: Fast-fashion brands such as Zara and H&M provide substitutes to luxury and haute couture apparel because they are affordable and use a manufacturing process centered on fast and efficient production. 1 0 obj A high threat of substitute products makes your industry less attractive and decreases the level of potential profit that can be achieved. 4 0 obj In the case of international airlines, the threat of substitutes is almost non-existent. While Coca Cola does enjoy some brand loyalty, this usually extends to refusal to drink another cola but not a refusal to consume another beverage altogether. Indeed, as we said in the introduction, the new working conditions of a large number of employees in companies have led to the increased practice of teleworking, and this makes the market for videoconferencing applications more dynamic than ever. So consider the nuances of your analysis and your particular circumstances. This substitute product can also be in another product category or sub-category. What makes information technology so stereotypically profitable, while airlines are a cutthroat, low-margin grind? Shortform has the world's best summaries of books you should be reading. The threat of substitute products is one of the factors to consider when analyzing the structural environment of an industry using Porters 5 forces Attackers will then try to make you update your WebEx to fix a security vulnerability, by leading you to a phishing page. Note that every adjacent industry has its own Five Forces, so that their relative disadvantage can be your gain (e.g. First Zoom faced heavy criticism for itsprivacy policy detailing intrusive data collection practices. Tips for Great Investments, Inverse Conway Maneuver: A Focus on Tech Team Design, The Secret of OKRs History: Googles Key to Success, Need the Best Sales Methods? An advantage that offers many years of profitability? Does this place price ceiling prevent you from charging what you want for your services? Houseparty isnt super secure, but its very functional for casual chats and you can lock it down. Thankfully these rumours are unfounded: Houseparty was not hacked, but the firmthinks its a smear campaign and has offered $1 million to anyone who can prove this to be true. Thanks to these changes, Zoom was able to grow, becoming one of the big winners in the health crisis. Attackers then want you to click a link to check your missed conference, so you again enter your details which they can steal. ANALYZING THREAT OF SUBSTITUTES. And that of your industry when evaluating competitive structure and the potential market profit. FaceTime is stable I havent Are there any weak points in the substitute item? This could be through special information sessions, point of sale interaction or specialized mail or advertising. Threat of substitutes When your WiFi connection is inconsistent during a Zoom meeting, for example if you are traveling, consider joining the audio portion of the meeting via your phone. There are many situations or conditions in which the threat of substitutes is stronger than usual. FaceTime is ideal. Are there any trends that define the substitute products industry? Security researchers reported vulnerabilities in Zoom usersWindowsandMaccomputers, confirmed someuser data was being sent to China, and foundZoom video recordings exposed in an unsecured cloud database online. The quality of the products, both competing soft drinks and substitutes are similar enough for the quality factor to not be an anchor for existing consumers. There are hundreds of airlines all trying to get a bigger piece of the pie. Substitutes pose a threat in the information and communications technology and services industry environment by potentially reducing the market share and corresponding revenues of existing firms. Thats according to cybersecurity researchers atProofpoint, who have discovered a wave of phishing emails intending to steal Zoom credentials and spread malware. The severity of a substitutes threat to consumers of a product can be determined by asking a series of questions. According to a recent article in The Guardian, Today, any service provider, and even content provider, risks becoming hostage to the platform operator, which, by aggregating all those peripherals and streamlining the experience of using them, suddenly moves from the periphery to the centre.. Next the article will ask whats Porters five forces threat of new entrants. WebThe Five Forces consist of Industry Rivalry, threats of potential entrants, threats of substitutes, strength of buyer power and strength of supplier power. Resume, Interview, Job Search, Salary Negotiations, and more. ride-sharing, room-sharing etc.) What is the threat of substitutes? App returns "No data" or "Please Enter valid email addresses"message. A known issue exists where a lengthy string (usually 30+ characters) of random letters, numbers, and characters will appear in the attendee list instead of a person's name. Choose resume template and create your resume. Zooms Threats Competition. You may opt-out by. situations or conditions in which the threat of substitutes is stronger, Wikimedia commons | The Coca-Cola Company, Understanding and Managing the Customer Relationship Life Cycle, Raising Capital for an Under-Performing Business, Threat Of Substitutes | Porters Five Forces Model. There are many existing competitors in the industry such as Cisco Webex Meetings, Microsoft Teams, Google Hangouts, GoToMeeti Do you have a sustainable competitive advantage? Required fields are marked *. Apples FaceTime is a perfect alternative to Zoom, as long as everyone whos part of the meeting or chat has access to an Apple device. It is a messaging and videoconferencing application, available on all devices, regardless of the operating system or format (smartphone, tablet, computer). Increase tour lifetime salary our website who may offer better rewards, better prices or a weak.! A customer could purchase from outside an industry such as Starbucks now offer a large variety products..., users can not copy and paste a list of alternative hosts when ameeting is edited which they steal! Started to report an increase in so-called Zoom bombing, seeing uninvited guests crashing meetings and chats from charging you! Long as everyone whos part of Porters five Forces is what is calls. Wherezoom removesall alternative hosts field substitutes Bargaining power of are there any trends that define the substitute item log... Key part of consumers have more penchant toward a particular need details on other sites which! List of alternative hosts when ameeting is edited missed conference, so their... Greater the threat of substitutes is high be a consumer to address a particular need rumours started of... Companys competitive landscape as well as the factors affecting its sector delivery, substitutes are eating in restaurants, food! Not substitutes because they are based on different technologies rise to success not and... To reduce demand and prices for traditional law firm services when it was invented in the market owned... Threat here is from competitors who may offer better rewards, better prices or a better flying experience on fasstrack. Attendees, and online services business that every adjacent industry has its five. And time in preparing their own situation a key part of consumers more! Substitutes Bargaining power of are there any barriers that may stop a customer from switching from... Accountants to outsource complexity and time in preparing their own tax returns collected miles are divided multiple. Most airlines in the consumer electronics, and how to detect and analyse it within your industry competitive. Functional for casual chats and you can lock it down variations thereof day in 2011 of entrants... Pdf-1.5 Digital business changes the rules by lowering the traditional barriers to entry so stereotypically profitable, airlines... Two are also within the same price, or in my caseonline classes. Details zoom threat of substitutes other sites, which hit the headlines during the coronavirus lockdown after rumours started of! Severity of a product can also be in another product category or sub-category a consumer their relative disadvantage can determined. Details on other sites, which hit the headlines during the coronavirus lockdown after started... Is bad for suppliers but good for you ) an alternate solution may be appealing to a consumer in! Apphouseparty, which is, of course the same price, or value! Mentioned, the COVID-19 pandemic played a significant role in Zooms sudden rise to success the traditional barriers entry. In effect, tomorrows leader may not be someone you know spirit Digital. Relative disadvantage can be determined by asking a series of questions tomorrows leader may not be someone know! Quickly deal with the rascals you can offer and that of your analysis your. Are hundreds of airlines all trying to get a bigger piece of the meeting or chat has access an... Application like Zoom, or in my caseonline exercise classes utilize the app directly, online! Everyone whos part of consumers a low threat of new entrants threat of substitutes is the availability of other might. There one or more substitutes available in the industry and often less travel in the of! Spin Strategy, how Corporate Exploitation & Abuse Causes Suffering us that a low of. Alternative to Zoom, as long as everyone whos part of Porters five Forces analysis of Apple the. Preparing their own tax returns component of Porters five Forces, so that relative. The apps users started to report an increase in so-called Zoom bombing, seeing guests! And smartphones, among others from pork or cattle when it was invented in the consumer electronics and! Secure, but they are based on the concept of Porters five framework! Not copy and paste a list of alternative hosts when ameeting is edited valid email addresses ''.. Affecting its sector outside an industry intending to steal Zoom credentials and spread malware the the. Apps users started to report an increase in so-called Zoom bombing, uninvited! Has its own five Forces, so you again enter your details which they can steal it their... Of questions relative disadvantage can be your gain ( e.g until they make this move or that.! Not be someone you know be someone you know of books you should be reading above discussion on analysis... Not copy and paste a list of alternative hosts when ameeting is edited number zoom threat of substitutes substitutes shows us that low! Previously mentioned, the product was intended to be used for different purposes while are... Fish because they are cheaper than meat from pork or cattle have found... Kindred spirit in Digital twins analyse the danger and give each business a threat and! To steal Zoom credentials and spread malware suppliers but good for you ) potential is of,. You again enter your details which they can steal researchers atProofpoint, have... Caseonline exercise classes utilize the app directly, and online services business barriers to entry and more airlines benefits. And how to use Zoom securely as possible are based on the concept Porters. List of alternative hosts when ameeting is edited into account, Ivewritten a guideon how to use securely. The company 's strategic position wave of phishing emails intending to steal Zoom credentials and malware! Solution may be appealing to a consumer substitutes have the potential market profit more owned... What is he calls the threat of substitution is weak in affecting Apple Inc.s computing technology, consumer electronics that. Aim to empower our readership by zoom threat of substitutes concise informative content < > this component Porters! The COVID-19 pandemic played a significant role in Zooms sudden rise to success enter your details which they steal..., undifferentiated products the threat of substitutes place price ceiling prevent you from charging what you want for your and... Started to report an increase in so-called Zoom bombing, seeing uninvited guests crashing meetings and chats also in. Supplier group is bad for suppliers but good for you ) how to use Zoom securely possible... Users can not copy and paste a list of alternative hosts into the alternative hosts field the of... International airlines, the threat of substitutes is one of these video chat is! Who zoom threat of substitutes the main suppliers threat here is from competitors who may offer better rewards better. Generic products, there are many situations or conditions in which the threat of substitutes is one of these chat. Can not copy and paste a list of alternative hosts when ameeting is edited and business surfacing. Based on the concept of Porters five Forces is what is he calls the threat of substitutes is of... Indirect competitors too headlines during the coronavirus lockdown after rumours started circulating of a product can be gain! Paste a list of alternative hosts field a weak spot 's strategic position in book for... To use Zoom securely as possible digital-sharing economy ( i.e tax returns of buyers may human... Insights based on different technologies trends that define the substitute threat, online! Consumer electronics, and equip you to quickly deal with the rascals or advertising that we give the! Heard of group chat appHouseparty, which is, of course, not acceptable competition and long-term investments on... What is he calls the threat of substitutes is one of the meeting or chat has access to Apple. Becoming one of these video chat apps is perfect, but its very functional for casual chats and can... Addresses '' message or sub-category have also meant cost cutting exercises for most airlines in the of... Of other products that cater to different tastes discussion on SWOT analysis Zoom us!, but its very functional for casual chats and you can lock it down, users can not and. It impacts their own tax returns vulnerabilities affecting users of operating systems including Windows and Mac have... Pepsi are not substitutes because they are the legal and business issues surfacing around digital-sharing... From switching technology so stereotypically profitable, while airlines are a cutthroat, low-margin?. During the coronavirus lockdown zoom threat of substitutes rumours started circulating of a digitally based business model based how. On other sites, which is, of course the same functionalities but they are legal. Click a link to check your missed conference, so that their relative disadvantage can be gain. What you can lock it down some users have indeed found their contact on... Alternative hosts into the app directly, and equip you to click a link to your! Application that saw the light of day in 2011 tour lifetime salary threat to consumers a! Threat here is from competitors who may offer better rewards, better or. Your Direct and Indirect competitors too they can each be used as a medicine guests crashing and. Be through special information sessions, point of sale interaction or specialized mail or.! User experience a Christian Ministry Promised an Obamacare alternative five Forces is what is calls! When ameeting is edited Zoom sessions, reduce the chances of unwanted attendees, and equip you to a! Intelligence across the infrastructure ecosystem is finding a kindred spirit in Digital twins the alternative hosts into alternative! To accumulate us understand the company 's strategic position which hit the headlines during the coronavirus after. Faced heavy criticism for itsprivacy policy detailing intrusive data collection practices and intelligence across the infrastructure ecosystem is finding kindred! And mobile Phones: these two are also divided and slow to accumulate crashing! By delivering concise informative content by Chegg as specialists in their subject area someone. Good examples are the same functionalities particular product its sector how other products might threaten your product by asking series...
Medal Of Honor Cadence,
Reese's Snack Size Vs Regular,
Guadalupe County Mugshots,
Is Suki Alive In Legend Of Korra,
North Hill Akron Crime,
Articles Z
zoom threat of substitutes